[Freeciv-Dev] Re: (PR#17996) Different bugs discoverd

["Johan Denis" <johan.denis@xxxxxxxxxx>]

<URL: http://bugs.freeciv.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=17996 >

I did some further testing and discovered folowing things:

problem 1#:Freeciv-2.1.0-beta1
                 non gtkclient: client mode      first attempt failed 
for security reason second attempt ok
                                  server/client mode on server ok on 
first attempt but on client same as above
                 gtkclient:        client mode   ok on first attempt
                                   server/client mode on server and 
client ok on first attempt
problem 2#Freeciv-2.1.0-beta1
                 non gtkclient: client mode      fails
                                  server/client mode on server ok but 
on client same as above
                 gtkclient:        client mode   ok
                                   server/client mode on server and client ok
problem 3#Freeciv-2.1.0-beta1
                 non gtkclient: client mode and server/client mode 
occurs when starting next turn and the game has to start the researching
                                      of future tech
                 gtkclient:        client mode and server/client mode 
no problem at all
problem 4#      still testing

Because I tested on the 2 version (non gtk and gtk) I discoverd also 
other problems
Problem on the command menu: gtk works as it should be
                                    non gtk : command that normaly 
are not aviable due to unit and/or technology restriction are not 
disabled in                                              the command 
menu but are not executed if their is a restriction on that command. Confusing
                                              example: each 
non-colonist unit should have the built city command disabled in the 
command                                      menu but the command 
will be only executed with the colonist. other example on a hill 
or                                        mountain tile you allraidy 
have build a mine but the command is still aviable on the 
command                                            menu but not executed.
                                              also related to the 
command menu but specific to the settlers and his upgrade are the 3 
tiles                                           change command. It 
should gave for exemple for a grasstile following command
                                                                                
                 I 
(irrigate or farming(on second irigation))
                                                                                
                 M(changing 
to forest)
                                                                                
                 O(terraforming 
to hill)
                                                                                
 but 
you see on the command menu following
                                                                                
                  I 
(irrigating to grassland(on first 
and 
second irigation
                                                                                
                 M(changing 
to grassland)
                                                                                
                 O(terraforming 
to grassland)
                                                 Dispite the wrong 
info on the command menu the commands are executed as they 
should                                             be. What means it 
cotribute to the confusing working of the command menu

Their are also other difference between the non gtk and the gtk 
version witch gives the gtk version a more user friendly and mature 
interface to play the game
Johan
At 09:48 23/06/2006, you wrote:

><URL: http://bugs.freeciv.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=17996 >
>
>For problems #3 and #4 it would really help to have a savegame that I
>can just load up and see the problem.
>
>-jason


I did some further testing and discovered folowing things:

problem 1#:Freeciv-2.1.0-beta1

        

        

non gtkclient:
client mode

     

first attempt
failed for security reason second attempt ok

        

        

        

         server/client mode on
server ok on first attempt but on client same as above

        

        

gtkclient:        client
mode

   

ok on first attempt

        

        

        

          server/client mode
on server and client ok on first attempt
problem 2#Freeciv-2.1.0-beta1

        

        

non gtkclient:
client mode

     

fails

        

        

        

         server/client mode on
server ok but on client same as above

        

        

gtkclient:        client
mode

   

ok

        

        

        

          server/client mode
on server and client ok 
problem 3#Freeciv-2.1.0-beta1

        

        

non gtkclient:
client mode and server/client mode occurs when starting next turn and the
game has to start the researching

        

        

of future tech

        

        

gtkclient:        client mode and
server/client mode no problem at all
problem 4#

      

still
testing

Because I tested on the 2 version (non gtk and gtk) I discoverd also
other problems
Problem on the command menu: gtk works as it should be

        

        

        

        

   non
gtk : command that normaly are not aviable due to unit and/or technology
restriction are not disabled in

        

        

        

        

     

     the
command menu but are not executed if their is a restriction on that
command. Confusing

        

        

        

        

        

     example: each non-colonist unit should have the
built city command disabled in the
command

 

        

        

        

        

     menu but the command will be only executed with
the colonist. other example on a hill or

  

        

        

        

        

     mountain tile you allraidy have build a mine but
the command is still aviable on the command

      

        

        

        

        

     menu but not executed.

        

        

        

        

        

     also related to the command menu but specific to
the settlers and his upgrade are the 3 tiles

     

        

        

        

        

     change command. It should gave for exemple for a
grasstile following command

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

I (irrigate or
farming(on second irigation))

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

M(changing to
forest)

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

O(terraforming to
hill)

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

but you see on
the command menu following

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

 I (irrigating to
grassland(on first and

       

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

second
irigation

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

M(changing to
grassland)

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

        

O(terraforming to
grassland)

        

        

        

        

        

        

Dispite the wrong
info on the command menu the commands are executed as they should

    

        

        

        

        

        

be. What means it
cotribute to the confusing working of the command menu

Their are also other difference between the non gtk and the gtk version
witch gives the gtk version a more user friendly and mature interface to
play the game
Johan
At 09:48 23/06/2006, you wrote:

> <URL:
>
> http://bugs.freeciv.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=17996 >
>
> For problems #3 and #4 it would really help to have a savegame that I
> can just load up and see the problem.
>
> -jason